Exit interviews are autopsies; try a stay interview

Your best legal assistant knows which partner needs a reminder, which client needs reassurance, and which printer requires a small act of faith.

When that person resigns, everyone suddenly has questions.

There's a better time to ask them.

A stay interview is simply a conversation about what makes someone want to keep working at your firm—and what makes that harder than it needs to be. No grand program required. A quiet half hour and a willingness to hear an inconvenient answer will do.

Five questions, before there's a farewell cake

  • What part of your work would you most like to keep doing? Start with what works. You may discover that a responsibility you consider minor is a major reason the person enjoys the job.
  • What regularly makes a good day harder? Listen for repeat friction: last-minute assignments, unclear priorities, weak coverage, or technology that turns simple tasks into expeditions.
  • When do you feel your work is most appreciated? People differ. Some value direct thanks; others want greater trust, development, or recognition that doesn't involve a public speech.
  • What would you like to learn or take on next? Don't assume a capable assistant wants the same desk, responsibilities, and ceiling indefinitely.
  • What could we realistically change in the next month that would make this a better place to work? A manageable improvement is more useful than a wish list nobody revisits.

This is not a rebuttal exercise

If the answer is “three partners give me urgent work at once,” resist explaining why all three partners are extremely busy.

The assistant probably noticed.

Ask for an example. Explore how priorities could be resolved. Don't promise confidentiality you can't maintain, and explain when you need to involve someone else to address an issue.

Keep the discussion separate from a compensation negotiation or performance critique. Those conversations matter, too, but combining everything can make candor feel risky.

The follow-up is the interview

Choose one or two actions, identify who owns them, and set a check-in. If something can't change, explain why. If it can, let the employee see progress.

Then make these conversations a regular habit, not a special invitation issued only when someone looks restless.

You won't prevent every departure. But you can stop treating a resignation as your first opportunity to learn how the job actually feels.

And that's a much nicer conversation to have before someone orders the cake.