Is it a pipeline problem or a pay problem?

“We can't find anyone.”

Maybe. But where, exactly, is everyone disappearing?

A recruiting problem can look like an empty inbox, a stack of unsuitable applications, or three excellent candidates who all say no. Those are different problems. Buying another job-board package won't necessarily solve all three.

Before changing everything, follow one opening from first impression to final decision.

1. Are the right people seeing the opportunity?

If few plausible candidates encounter the role, look at sourcing. Is the title recognizable? Is the location clear? Are you reaching the right practice area, experience level, or professional community?

A highly specialized associate search and an office support opening may need different channels. Reposting the same ad in the same place is activity, not necessarily a broader search.

2. Do interested people actually apply?

If people see the opening but don't apply, examine the invitation.

Is the compensation competitive for the role and market? Are schedule expectations clear? Does the application require twenty minutes of retyping a résumé?

Check the requirements, too. You may be asking for expertise your budget doesn't support—or insisting on experience someone could reasonably acquire with training.

3. Do qualified applicants make it through?

If promising people withdraw during interviews, inspect your process before blaming their commitment.

Look for long gaps, repeated conversations with no clear purpose, inconsistent descriptions of the job, and interviewers who disagree about what success means.

Ask candidates about their timing. A responsive competing firm can become the default choice while your partners are still comparing calendars.

4. Do your offers get a yes?

If qualified finalists repeatedly decline, ask for feedback without arguing with it. Track the reasons you actually hear, and distinguish them from your guesses.

Pay may be the issue. So may benefits, commute, supervision, flexibility, workload, or another opportunity that simply fits better.

Compare the whole package with current market information rather than the salary you paid the last person several years ago.

Keep a small scorecard

For each search, record qualified applicants, interviews, withdrawals, offers, acceptances, and time between steps. Add the stated reasons people leave the process. A modest local firm doesn't need a dashboard with its own IT department to notice a pattern.

Then change the part that's leaking. Broader sourcing, clearer expectations, faster decisions, and better compensation solve different things.

Sometimes the pipeline is too narrow. Sometimes the offer isn't attractive enough. Sometimes both are true.

The useful answer starts with where you lose people—not with how loudly you announce that nobody is available.