The 48-hour rule

Your favorite candidate is available Thursday. Three partners can meet Tuesday. The fourth can do the following Wednesday, provided the deposition wraps up.

Somewhere in this scheduling masterpiece, another firm makes an offer.

A 30-lawyer firm doesn't need a giant recruiting department to lose a good candidate. It just needs a calendar nobody owns.

Forty-eight hours is a habit, not a hiring deadline

Here's a useful internal rule: within two business days of a meaningful interview, give the candidate a clear next step or an honest update.

That doesn't mean hiring someone after one conversation. It doesn't mean skipping references, checking credentials casually, or rushing the candidate's decision.

It means silence isn't your default project-management tool.

Strong associates and paralegals may be talking with several employers. Offers can arrive within days. Your careful deliberation and their active search are happening on different clocks.

Do the slow thinking before the first interview

Before inviting anyone in, settle three things:

  • Who actually decides? Gather useful input, but distinguish advisers from decision-makers.
  • What are you evaluating? Agree on the essential experience, responsibilities, and compensation range before everyone develops a different ideal candidate.
  • When can the next step happen? Reserve interview time now instead of starting another calendar scavenger hunt later.

Then give one person responsibility for keeping the process moving. In a smaller firm, that may be the administrator, hiring partner, or recruiting contact. Whoever it is needs authority to chase an answer, not merely permission to send reminders.

An update is better than a disappearing act

If a trial or client emergency interrupts the process, say so. Explain what happens next and when you'll check back. Don't promise an offer date you can't control.

Ask about the candidate's timing, too. Another pending decision is useful information, not an invitation to pressure them or demand details about competing firms.

The same courtesy applies to legal assistants and business staff. They shouldn't need to reach the associate salary band to qualify for a return call.

Speed alone won't rescue a weak opportunity. But a clear, responsive process gives a good opportunity a chance.

Think of the 48-hour rule as basic hospitality: if you've invited someone into a conversation about their future, don't leave them standing in the hallway.